기타살롱의 리브라님의 글 퍼왔습니다..
..................................................................
델캄프 포럼에 재미있는 글이 있어서 가져왔습니다.
가계도도 있네요.^^
In an earlier thread the question of a “Granada School” of builders was raised, leading to heated discussion regarding whether the term holds realistically meaningful validity. Now that passions have subsided, and without wishing to take a side in the matter, I’d like to share my understanding of the term strictly as evidenced by a chronological overview of the historical record. Perhaps this background information will help others elucidate their positions.
Evidently the first coinage of the term “Granada School” in English may be attributed to a translation of words by Eusebio Rioja, who published the book Inventario de Guitarreros Granadinos, (1875-1975) in 1976. George Clinton and John Roberts (Editor and History Columnist of the English magazine “Guitar”, respectively), visited Granada in 1976 and Roberts, as a result, published an article entitled “The Guitar in Granada” in the February, 1977 issue (pages 9-11). Roberts quotes from it extensively (in his own translation) in his article, and specifically quotes Rioja’s phrase in the introduction, "la escuela guitarrera granadina", as “the Granada School of makers”. Roberts then goes on to cover Rioja’s list of Granada makers.
Ivor Mairants, the English jazz guitarist and classical enthusiast turned guitar dealer (who was importing and selling guitars by Antonio Marín Montero, Manuel Bellido, and Antonio Raya Pardo among others already), covered six “Guitarreros of Granada” in his 1980 book My Fifty Fretting Years (pages 356-357) without using the term, however.
Rioja published a second edition of his book, this one entitled Inventario de Guitarreros Granadinos, (1875-1983), in conjunction with the 11th Congresso Nacional de Actividades Flamencas in Granada in 1983. Mairants was in attendance, met Rioja, and returned to England to publish the two-part article “Granada: City of Guitar Makers” in the March/April and May/June issues of “Classical Guitar” magazine (pages 71-74 and 59-60, respectively). Like Roberts’ article seven years earlier, Mairants covers Rioja’s now extended list of Granada luthiers. While not using the term “Granada School”, Mairants opts instead to use “pupils of the House of Ferrer”, “the school of Ferrer”, and “the Ferrer school”.
The aforementioned George Clinton returned to Granada in 1988 for a week’s visit, thereafter writing a series of twelve articles entitled “Escuela Granadina de Luthiers” (The Granada School of Luthiers) in “Guitar International” magazine from September 1988 through 1989. Not merely parroting Rioja’s term, Clinton instead was referring to an actual organization called the Escuela. In his words, “The Escuela was formed in 1987—in truth to bureaucratize an already close association—and comprises twelve makers” (namely, Antonio Marín Montero, José Lopez Bellido, Juan Miguel Carmona, Rafael Moreno, Germán Pérez Barranco, Antonio Raya Pardo, José Marín Plazuelo, Manuel Diaz, Bernd Martin, René Baarslag, and Jonathan Hinves). In addition to his introductory article, essays in future issues were each devoted to one of the makers (save Manuel Diaz, who was unavailable). Each essay bore the main title, “Escuela Granadina de Luthiers”.
Clinton was the first to define the Escuela vis-à-vis the Madrid (i.e. Ramirez) “School” of builders. He states, “As a school, the present makers share several characteristics…”. He then goes on to list:
1. smaller plantilla
2. built up from the top
3. Spruce tops
4. Top domed on solera
5. Torres type strutting (usually 7)
6. Peones instead of continuous lining
7. 650mm scale length
8. Mosaic rosette construction technique
9. French polish finish
A year later, in 1990, Lisa Hurlong (aka “Lisa de Granada”) published her article on select Granada makers, after having purchased an Antonio Marín Montero while on a concert trip to Granada in 1979, and having reacquainted herself with Granada in 1984. The article, “Guitarra Granada Ole” appeared in the summer, 1990, issue of “Soundboard” magazine (pages 14-21), and covered Antonio Marín Montero, José Marín Plazuelo, René Baarslag, José Lopez Bellido, Jonathan Hinves, and Bernd Martin. (Later, in the winter, 1992, issue of “American Lutherie”, she covered Antonio Raya Pardo in a separate article). Nowhere in her writings, however, does Lisa de Granada use the term “Granada School”.
John Huber’s book, The Development of the Modern Guitar (Bold Strummer, 1991, and second edition, 1994), is careful to use the term “Granada School” in double quotes, as does Kenny Hill in his 2001 essay, “Visit to Legendary Granada” on his website.
In summary, then, it would appear that “Granada School” as a term in English has its origin in print in a translation of the 1976 writings of Eusebio Rioja. An actual Granada School was formalized in 1987, and George Clinton wrote extensively about it and its makers in English from 1988-1989. (Perhaps one of our Granada contributors might enlighten us as to the fate of the Escuela as an organized body of luthiers).
Aside from the formal organization which utilized the name, “Granada School” has, it seems, come to be associated with virtually any builder in Granada whose guitars exhibit most of the characteristics that Clinton enumerated in his 1988 article. In addition, it would seem that, as Mairants insinuated, luthiers of the “Granada School” can trace their lineage of teachers back to the House of Ferrer. Unlike the “Madrid School”, where few lineages spanned more than two generations save for the House of Ramirez, in Granada we find fathers teaching sons (e.g. Manuel and Jesus Bellido, Antonio Durán and Eduardo Durán Ferrer, Antonio Raya Pardo and Antonio Raya Ferrer, and Bernd and Lucas Martin), uncles teaching nephews (e.g. Benito and Eduardo Ferrer, Antonio Marín Montero and both Paco Santiago Marín and José Marín Plazuelo), brothers teaching brothers (e.g. Manuel and José Lopez Bellido), brothers-in-law teaching brothers-in-law (e.g. José Lopez Bellido and Antonio Raya Pardo), husbands teaching wives (e.g. René Baarslag and Ana Espinosa Rodriguez), etc. Hence familiarity is literally key, with the exception of expatriates, of course. Even then, for example, Antonio Marín Montero has referred to René Baarslag as being “like a son to me”.
Cheers,
David Gansz
P.S. The renowned historian, author, luthier, and guitar dealer Richard Brune, having read the above, has contacted me and graciously shared the following information: Brook Zern, author of a regularly appearing column on the Spanish tradition of lutherie in the publication "Flamenco Information Service Library Newsletter" in 1968, having finished a multi-part series on the Madrid school, indicated that his next month's installment would be on the "Granada school". So Richard, without having actually surveyed his vast archival collection of literature on the subject for verification, believes this to be the first appearance of the term in English. Interestingly, Richard notes that, in the actual article (No. 8, Vol 1, page 3...December, 1968), Zern states, "Granada has its own group of constructors (I'd hesitate to call it a School)". I am very grateful to Richard, an acknowledged expert in these matters, for freely sharing this information with us.
번호 | 제목 | 글쓴이 | 날짜 | 조회 수 |
---|---|---|---|---|
1434 |
황칠나무
17 ![]() |
고정석 | 2009.06.26 | 20533 |
1433 | 황칠나무 2 | 콩쥐 | 2009.06.25 | 8537 |
1432 | 동아리연주회곡을 정해야하는데..ㅠ.. 2 | 동아리회장 | 2009.06.25 | 7305 |
1431 |
하드케이스 백팩
![]() |
mauro | 2009.06.15 | 11713 |
1430 |
기타 구조해석 - animation 4
![]() |
EchoOff | 2009.06.11 | 10315 |
1429 |
기타 구조해석 - animation 3
![]() |
EchoOff | 2009.06.11 | 8813 |
1428 |
기타 구조해석 - animation 2
![]() |
EchoOff | 2009.06.11 | 8999 |
1427 |
기타 구조해석 - animation 1
8 ![]() |
EchoOff | 2009.06.11 | 10540 |
1426 |
기타 구조해석 - 현 장력에 의한 상판의 변형
4 ![]() |
EchoOff | 2009.06.11 | 11246 |
1425 |
기타 구조해석 - 진동 모드 2
1 ![]() |
EchoOff | 2009.06.11 | 10909 |
1424 |
기타 구조해석 - 진동 모드 1
1 ![]() |
EchoOff | 2009.06.11 | 11580 |
1423 |
기타 구조해석 - 유한요소 모델
6 ![]() |
EchoOff | 2009.06.11 | 13110 |
1422 | 왼손편한기타 6 | 두식이네 | 2009.06.01 | 9227 |
1421 |
기타를 만드는 남자
70 ![]() |
최동수 | 2009.05.28 | 13588 |
1420 | 기타가 제작되고나서 제 소리를 내려면, 시간이 필요한 건가요? 16 | 몰라용 | 2009.05.26 | 8745 |
1419 | 픽업 1 | 콩쥐 | 2009.05.22 | 7577 |
1418 |
독특한 기타 디자인이네요
6 ![]() |
바실리스크 | 2009.05.14 | 11394 |
1417 |
울프톤 이해를 돕기 위한 그림입니다 ^^
64 ![]() |
EchoOff | 2009.05.12 | 13926 |
1416 | 세고비아>야마시타>앙헬 8 | 종이컵 | 2009.04.26 | 7809 |
1415 | 클래식기타 튜닝문제..... 8 | 기타맨 | 2009.04.07 | 10611 |
1414 | 장 라리비 기타 제작 과정 홍보 영상 6 | jkfs | 2009.03.17 | 9091 |
1413 | 대중음악에서 다현 기타 3 | abcde-kld | 2009.03.14 | 6485 |
1412 | 다현기타 사용자분들의 경험담을 듣고 싶습니다. 63 | 신정하 | 2009.03.12 | 10748 |
1411 | 최동수님 ...... 16 | Kyung Yoo | 2009.03.01 | 7637 |
1410 |
[re] Kasha model의 헤드 모양
3 ![]() |
최동수 | 2008.12.11 | 6235 |
1409 |
Kasha model의 헤드 모양
8 ![]() |
최동수 | 2008.12.11 | 8824 |
1408 |
[re] 바이스게버 카피모델의 헤드사진
13 ![]() |
최동수 | 2008.12.11 | 6751 |
1407 |
[re] 바이스게버 카피모델의 헤드사진
6 ![]() |
최동수 | 2008.12.11 | 7249 |
1406 |
하젤 스프르스 사진
4 ![]() |
콩쥐 | 2008.12.01 | 9089 |
1405 |
기타제작아카데미에서 제작한 스페인식 네크의 근접사진
1 ![]() |
백철진 | 2008.11.29 | 9769 |
1404 | 좀더 길은 기타줄이 없을까요? 7 | 자유 | 2008.11.25 | 7734 |
1403 |
로마닐로스가 올해(2008년) 의 제작자로 선정한 David Merrin Guitar
2 ![]() |
고정석 | 2008.10.19 | 18630 |
1402 |
Jose Ramirez 1 Guitar 1909
3 ![]() |
고정석 | 2008.10.18 | 18632 |
1401 | Classic & Flamenco Guitar Plans | 고정석 | 2008.10.17 | 11025 |
1400 | 기타 전판의 재질에 관한 질문. 17 | 쏠레아 | 2008.10.06 | 11583 |
1399 | 원하는 줄만 골라서 눌러주는 Capo 소개합니다. 2 | 사꼬™ | 2008.09.30 | 7081 |
1398 |
사운드홀에 스피커 달기.
6 ![]() |
쏠레아 | 2008.09.24 | 10187 |
1397 |
브릿지에 대한 질문.
10 ![]() |
쏠레아 | 2008.09.22 | 8484 |
1396 | 기타에서의 공명현상 7 | 쏠레아 | 2008.09.18 | 11521 |
1395 |
[re] 수장건조
6 ![]() |
콩쥐 | 2008.09.15 | 7396 |
1394 | 0프렛에 대해... 제로프렛??? 28 | 쏠레아 | 2008.09.12 | 11939 |
1393 | 기타의 음량에 대한 한탄, 억울함... 19 | 쏠레아 | 2008.09.08 | 11844 |
1392 | 스테파노 그론도나와의 인터뷰 5 | 신정하 | 2008.09.08 | 6977 |
1391 | 음의 분리도와 원달성 8 | 쏠레아 | 2008.09.08 | 8221 |
1390 | 기타에서 일어나는 재미있는 현상. 15 | 쏠레아 | 2008.09.08 | 8017 |
1389 |
이런 기타 이름을 뭐라해야.... ?
13 ![]() |
콩쥐 | 2008.09.07 | 9453 |
1388 | 울림통? 공명통? 어느 것이 맞습니까? 24 | 쏠레아 | 2008.09.07 | 7924 |
1387 | 현고에 대하여 38 | 최동수 | 2008.09.04 | 19833 |
1386 |
브릿지개조 기타
12 ![]() |
훈 | 2008.09.04 | 14625 |
1385 | Contraversial Violinmaker Nagyvary 28 | Kyung Yoo | 2008.08.31 | 6915 |
1384 |
Bracing patterns by Descendant Guitar Makers of Manuel Ramirez
2 ![]() |
고정석 | 2008.08.30 | 11025 |
1383 |
Bracing patterns by Descendant Guitar Makers of Jose Ramirez 1
![]() |
고정석 | 2008.08.30 | 12176 |
1382 |
하현주 각도에 대한 생각
20 ![]() |
쏠레아 | 2008.08.28 | 19267 |
1381 |
[re] 라미레스 상현주
3 ![]() |
최동수 | 2008.08.27 | 7336 |
1380 | [re] 기타의 장력이 센 이유는? 18 | 하진 | 2008.08.22 | 12022 |
1379 |
Tap Tone과 Tone wood – 나무의 특성과 악기의 음향 (A. 재료와 음질)
6 ![]() |
bluejay | 2008.08.22 | 15286 |
1378 |
[re] Laminated Perimeter Frame
![]() |
최동수 | 2008.08.21 | 7085 |
1377 | 울림통 이야기. 2 | 쏠레아 | 2008.08.21 | 9106 |
1376 |
Laminated Perimeter Frame
3 ![]() |
최동수 | 2008.08.20 | 6839 |
1375 |
[re] 장력(Tension)과 액션(Action)
12 ![]() |
그레이칙 | 2008.08.19 | 8584 |
1374 | 장력(Tension)과 액션(Action) 44 | 쏠레아 | 2008.08.18 | 16887 |
1373 |
나무의 특성 (PDF 자료)
2 ![]() |
bluejay | 2008.08.13 | 7541 |
1372 |
Tap Tone과 Tone wood – 나무의 구조와 특성 (A. 재료와 음질)
5 ![]() |
bluejay | 2008.08.12 | 14550 |
1371 |
Tap Tone과 Tone wood – Tap Tone의 진동모드 (A. 재료와 음질)
2 ![]() |
bluejay | 2008.08.12 | 6667 |
1370 | 기타의 과학(2) 39 | 쏠레아 | 2008.08.11 | 9492 |
1369 | 기타의 과학 30 | 쏠레아 | 2008.08.11 | 12664 |
1368 |
Georg Bolin 11 string alto guitar
32 ![]() |
무동자 | 2008.08.10 | 8119 |
1367 | 기타의 장력이 센 이유는? 87 | 궁금 | 2008.08.09 | 15282 |
1366 |
명기에의 길라잡이
312 ![]() |
최동수 | 2008.08.09 | 29837 |
1365 |
하드케이스에 수납가방 만들기
2 ![]() |
음표 | 2008.08.04 | 10294 |
1364 |
기타 주변 용품 (3) 기타 써포트
11 ![]() |
음표 | 2008.08.03 | 9559 |
1363 |
기타 주변 용품 (2) 케이스
5 ![]() |
음표 | 2008.08.03 | 10303 |
1362 |
기타 주변 용품 (1) 제습제
3 ![]() |
음표 | 2008.08.03 | 11310 |
1361 | Göran Söllscher의 11현 기타 소개 13 | so many strings | 2008.07.31 | 9171 |
1360 | 결과는? 결론은? 9 | 최동수 | 2008.07.29 | 8318 |
1359 |
슈퍼칩
1 ![]() |
콩쥐 | 2008.07.24 | 13017 |
1358 |
기타의 수리와 관리
16 ![]() |
최동수 | 2008.07.19 | 10294 |
1357 | 셀락칠 마무리를 콤파운드로 하는걸... 2 | 대왕세손 | 2008.07.14 | 7371 |
1356 |
[re] Bouchet와 Weissgerber
![]() |
최동수 | 2008.07.12 | 6191 |
1355 |
[re] Bouchet와 Weissgerber
![]() |
최동수 | 2008.07.11 | 5343 |
1354 |
[re] Bouchet와 Weissgerber
![]() |
최동수 | 2008.07.11 | 5781 |
1353 |
[re] Bouchet와 Weissgerber
13 ![]() |
최동수 | 2008.07.11 | 6633 |
1352 |
[re] Bouchet와 Weissgerber
![]() |
최동수 | 2008.07.11 | 5881 |
1351 |
Bouchet와 Weissgerber
24 ![]() |
최동수 | 2008.07.11 | 9043 |
1350 | 오아시스 가습기와 개구리알~ 12 | JS | 2008.07.06 | 16115 |
1349 | 제품별 쉘락칠의 차이 1 | 브들레헵 | 2008.06.26 | 8736 |
1348 |
스프루스 색깔 질문
4 ![]() |
昊 | 2008.06.23 | 9542 |
1347 | 기타 음향판의 설계에 대하여 4 | 최동수 | 2008.05.29 | 9690 |
1346 | 기타 음향판의 구조적 검토 | 최동수 | 2008.05.29 | 8930 |
1345 | 기타의 음향판에 관하여 | 최동수 | 2008.05.29 | 8253 |
1344 | The Guitar and its Woods 2 | 고정석 | 2008.05.29 | 11417 |
1343 | JOSE RAMIREZ 1A 에 관해서 9 | 최동수 | 2008.05.14 | 8495 |
1342 | Jose Ramirez AE 모델 5 | 바하조아 | 2008.05.13 | 8278 |
1341 | 무광우레탄 vs 유광우레탄? 5 | 궁금 | 2008.05.05 | 10446 |
1340 | 쉘락칠 할 때요... 3 | 쉘락 | 2008.04.22 | 6277 |
1339 |
GSP 기타 줄
2 ![]() |
GSP | 2008.03.31 | 7414 |
1338 |
기타현 쌩뚱맞게 거는방법.
12 ![]() |
콩쥐 | 2008.02.22 | 9032 |
1337 | 세고비아의 명기에 대한 동영상. 1 | 콩쥐 | 2008.02.03 | 6830 |
1336 |
광주시민항쟁과 기타.
12 ![]() |
콩쥐 | 2008.01.21 | 6671 |
1335 |
최원호님의 CEDARUCE GUITAR.
2 ![]() |
콩쥐 | 2008.01.21 | 7614 |
Designed by sketchbooks.co.kr / sketchbook5 board skin
Sketchbook5, 스케치북5
Sketchbook5, 스케치북5
Sketchbook5, 스케치북5
Sketchbook5, 스케치북5